Christa Pike & The Murder of Colleen Slemmer
Listen To The Full Story Here: bio.site/beerswithqueers
She was just 18 years old when she became the youngest woman on death row in modern U.S. history. Christa Pike wasn’t just a troubled teen she was a storm of obsession, jealousy, and violent fantasy, wrapped in a skin of ritual and rage. In 1995 Knoxville, Tennessee, her name became synonymous with horror after a murder so cruel, so methodical, and so deeply disturbing, that it left even seasoned investigators shaken.
The victim, 19, year, old Colleen Slemmer, was a fellow student at a job corps training program. Christa believed wrongly that Colleen was trying to seduce her boyfriend. That delusion turned deadly. What began as a plan to “teach her a lesson” escalated into one of the most savage killings in Tennessee history. Armed with a box cutter and a pentagram carved into her skin, Christa lured Colleen into a secluded area near the University of Tennessee campus. What followed was a prolonged, ritualistic assault that blurred the line between a jealous vendetta and a satanic sacrifice.
This episode takes you deep into the twisted mind of a killer obsessed not just with control, but with power spiritual and sexual. We explore the dark symbolism behind the crime, the disturbing diary entries Christa kept, and the shocking level of cruelty she showed not only during the murder but after, bragging about it openly. As the investigation unfolds, we look at the culture of violence and manipulation among teens in the mid, 1990s, the media frenzy that followed, and the legal battle that continues to this day.
Through it all, we ask: What makes a teen turn into a killer? And what role did gender, identity, and belonging play in this infamous crime?
This case isn’t just disturbing it’s unforgettable.
Beers With Queers: A True Crime Podcast
Welcome to Beers With Queers, the true crime podcast where we dive into the darkest, most twisted cases and involving the LGBTQ+ community and always with a queer perspective. Hosted by Jordi and Brad, we cover everything from notorious serial killers to unsolved mysteries, cults, and bizarre crimes.
Join us for in, depth storytelling, chilling details, queer history and really gay commentary. So, whether you're here for the crimes, the beers, or the queers, you're in the right place. So, grab a drink, get cozy, and let’s talk true crime!
Subscribe now and never miss an episode!
🎧 Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, Audible or wherever you get your podcasts
Listen AD FREE On Patreon
Listen On Apple Podcast
Listen On Spotify For Podcasters
Listen On Spotify
Listen On Amazon Music
Listen On Audible
Listen On Pocket Casts
Follow Us On Instagram
Follow Us On Facebook
Follow us on Instagram @beerswithqueerspod or Facebook Beers With Queers: A True Crime Podcast for updates and extra content!
Cheers, queers!
Keywords: Christa Pike, Colleen Slemmer, Knoxville murder, satanic killing, teen killers, female killers on death row, Tennessee true crime, Job Corps murder, 1995 Knoxville murder, satanic panic, pentagram murder, ritualistic teen killing, LGBTQ+ true crime podcast, Beers With Queers, queer crime storytelling, Christa Pike diary, teen obsession murder, young women on death row, Knoxville unsolved crimes, cult, like teen violence